The Democrat oysterman Graham Platner, who is currently leading the primary race against Janet Mills, has become a controversial figure in Maine politics. The winner of this primary will face Sen. Susan Collins in the general election. Platner’s candidacy has drawn significant attention—not all of it positive.
One of the major points of contention is Platner’s tattoo. He reportedly had a Nazi Totenkopf symbol tattoo, which he now claims to have covered up with a Celtic design. Despite being a known history buff, Platner has said he did not understand the meaning of the original tattoo. His critics are skeptical of this explanation.
Platner’s online behavior has also stirred controversy. He has a history of tweeting inflammatory remarks, including calling white people and rural Americans “racist” and “stupid.” Additionally, he has made homophobic comments and referred to all police officers as “bastards” in 2021. He is also known to be a member of a radical communist group.
Despite these controversies, Platner maintains strong support within the Democratic Party. High-profile figures like Sen. Bernie Sanders have stood by him. Sanders emphasized Platner’s military service, noting that he served four tours as a Marine and has dealt with PTSD following his combat experience. “He got good treatment at the VA and has worked hard to get his life together,” Sanders said.
A recent University of New Hampshire poll, conducted from October 16 to 21, shows Platner leading Mills by a 34-point margin—58% to 24% among likely primary voters, with 14% undecided. This survey came after revelations of Platner’s controversial social media posts but before his announcement about covering up the tattoo. Platner’s popularity and large crowds at campaign events suggest he is energizing a Democratic Party that has struggled in Maine since former President Donald Trump returned to power.
Some Democratic leaders have downplayed Platner’s controversies. Senator Peter Welch of Vermont described Platner as “exciting” and expressed confidence that “Mainers will figure it out.” Similarly, Sen. Ben Ray Lujan, former leader of House Democrats’ campaign operations, called Platner “inspiring” but encouraged him to be fully transparent about his past.
Meanwhile, many see Platner as an unappealing candidate who should perhaps stick to oyster farming. His controversies provide a sharp contrast to Sen. Susan Collins, who, according to some observers, looks increasingly favorable by comparison.
Platner’s campaign continues to divide opinion, with supporters praising his energy and military background, while critics question his suitability as a Democratic nominee given his past statements and symbols. As the June 2026 primary approaches, Maine voters will have to weigh these factors carefully when choosing their candidate to challenge Sen. Collins.
https://www.independentsentinel.com/the-oysterman-with-the-nazi-tattoo-leads-by-34-points/
